Matt Dinniman's Dungeon Crawler Carl takes one of fantasy's oldest setups and throws it into a blender with reality television, apocalyptic horror, and video game logic, creating a series that has evolved into one of the biggest breakout hits in modern speculative fiction. The premise is fairly simple, starting with a fight for survival inside an alien-dominated game show that escalates into a sprawling saga of bizarre monsters, convoluted mechanics, and a talking cat with an ego to match. Beneath all of its bloodshed and absurdity, however, lies a surprisingly heartfelt story about survival in a system designed to exploit its participants, not unlike James Dashner’s The Maze Runner and Suzanne Collins’ The Hunger Games.
With eight books in the series, there's plenty of dungeon crawling to rank. Goodreads scores offer a useful snapshot of which adventures have resonated most with readers, but with every book holding a rating well above 4.3 stars, you won't find a single dud in this franchise. As fans eagerly await the ninth installment’s release next year, which Dinniman calls the first half of his planned two-part series conclusion, now is the perfect moment to look back at how the crawl has scored so far.
Here's every Dungeon Crawler Carl book ranked by its Goodreads score. Of all the Dungeon Crawler Carl books, The Dungeon Anarchist's Cookbook is the one most likely to test readers' patience, but that's not to say the third installment is a disappointment. Book three introduces readers to the Fourth Floor, which plunges Carl and his ex-girlfriend’s obnoxious cat, Donut, into the Iron Tangle, a nightmarish subway system where navigating the maze of trains, stations, and monsters can feel almost as grueling to the reader as it does for the crawlers.
The complicated geography is central to the challenge, but it also makes this installment more mechanically demanding than its predecessors. Still, Carl and Donut's increasingly desperate attempts to survive the Fourth Floor, alongside the introduction of greater cooperation between crawlers, make for compelling reading. Its comparatively lower score when set against the entire series reflects a divisive setting, not a lack of imagination.
Every great dungeon crawl needs a compelling reason to keep descending, and Dinniman's debut delivers one of the strangest imaginable. After an apocalyptic event transforms Earth into a deadly, televised game show, Carl finds himself fighting for survival alongside his ex-girlfriend's unusually opinionated feline, Princess Donut. It’s a gleefully unhinged blend of LitRPG mechanics, gruesome monsters, and reality television satire.
While clearly not ranked among his finest, there's a refreshing simplicity to this first outing, before the mythology and cast grow considerably more complicated. Carl and Donut's partnership is the real draw in this first episode, giving the carnage an emotional anchor as they fight for survival across the first two floors. Its lower placement is hardly a stain on its reputation; it simply reflects how much more ambitious the series has grown since its inception.
Extract — continue reading at the source.
