Pennsylvania has become the latest state to restrict students' cellphone use at school, joining a rapidly growing nationwide push to remove smartphones and other personal devices from classrooms. Federal data based on responses from 1,490 public schools found that more than half of school leaders believed cellphone use had hurt academic performance, and nearly three-quarters reported a negative effect on mental health as well as attention-span. Department of Education said in August that “cellphones and algorithm-driven social media” can distract students from learning, but said states and local communities should decide how technology is used in schools.
Governor Josh Shapiro signed Senate Bill 1014 into law on Monday, requiring schools across Pennsylvania to adopt "bell-to-bell" policies prohibiting students from possessing and using personal mobile devices throughout the school day. "Technology is a powerful tool, but it's also a powerful distraction," Shapiro said, adding that parents and teachers had raised concerns about children being distracted by their devices and spending less time building relationships in person. The restrictions cover not only lessons but also lunch, recess and periods between classes.
Schools must adopt and implement compliant policies by the beginning of the 2027-28 school year. The legislation applies broadly to school districts, intermediate units, career and technical schools, charter and regional charter schools, cyber charter schools and private and nonpublic schools. Exceptions are permitted for documented medical, disability or special education needs, and also for English-language learning devices and certain pre-approved instructional purposes.
Pennsylvania is part of a much broader nationwide shift, although states differ significantly in how far their restrictions go. The Education Commission of the States nonprofit reported in July that at least 40 states had “enacted policies related to cell phone use in schools,” ranging from requirements that districts develop their own policies to prohibitions covering the full school day. https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/30706936/ These states have rules extending beyond classroom instruction across essentially the full school day, although there are differences in grades covered and implementation dates: Massachusetts could also impose a statewide restriction. If passed, S.2581 would require policies prohibiting students from using personal electronic devices on school grounds during the school day.
While the states above have enacted stricter bell-to-bell restrictions, other states have statewide requirements that take a different approach, either restricting cellphone use primarily during classroom time, or requiring individual school districts to develop their own policies. Those states are Alaska, Arizona, California, Colorado, Delaware, Hawaii, Idaho, Iowa, Kentucky, Michigan, Minnesota, Nebraska, Nevada, New Mexico, North Carolina, Tennessee, West Virginia, Wisconsin and Wyoming. The rules vary between states.
For example, Michigan's HB 4141 requires school districts and public school academies to prohibit students from using wireless communication devices during class, but allows districts to impose additional restrictions if they choose. California takes a more locally controlled approach. AB 3216 requires school districts, county education boards and charter schools to develop and adopt policies that limit or prohibit smartphone use, rather than imposing one uniform statewide bell-to-bell ban.
Extract — continue reading at the source.
